Thinking Activity : Movie Screening of the play Waiting for Godot
Welcome readers!
This blog is about some points to be ponder it. We have to give our internation to all questions.
Q. 1 What connection do you see in the setting (“A country road. A tree.Evening.”) of the play and these paintings?
In this painting we find it as very romantic but in the movie of the play " Waiting for Godot there this picture is Shawn as very dull. Existential vision of life is not romantic. Nothing to be done in the play, two ,Vladimir and Estragon are waiting for Godot but it never comes. Setting of the play is very differentiate country road, tree and evening is there but not as it seems in this painting.
Q. 2 The tree is the only important ‘thing’ in the setting. What is the importance of tree in both acts? Why does Beckett grow a few leaves in Act II on the barren tree - The tree has four or five leaves - ?
He look's a barren tree with green leaves. The Barrenness of nature is seen here in the picture. At every moment we are waiting for something. The setting of the play tree is always there in both act. It deep satire on the all theological concerns.
Tree also give an idea of strength and waiting. Maybe tree have four, five leaves
Q.3 In both Acts, evening falls into night and moon rises. How would you like to interpret this ‘coming of night and moon’ when actually they are waiting for Godot?
Night and Moon, Waiting for Godot
Here we can say that night and moon both we can see. Darkness and light we find in the picture. Darkness we can say that it is waiting and Shines we can say theirs believed that every moon light comes with allusion for Godot. It seems like Timepasses. Nothing to be done.
Q. 4 The director feels the setting with some debris. Can you read any meaning in the contours of debris in the setting of the play?
Yes, the director used debris in the setting. Director wants to reminded an effects of World War. Nothing is permanent the life. That way we can see the use of debris.
Q. 5 The play begins with the dialogue “Nothing to be done”. How does the theme of ‘nothingness’ recurs in the play?
"Nothing to be done " itself suggest that waiting for Godot can never end. In our life we are waiting for something, somebody without knowing ,that for whom we are waiting? What is the purpose of our waiting? Why are we waiting? Existentialism says that all we are doing ,it is nothing, kind of timepass. We know that doing something is meaningless but still we are doing. Play starting with this dialogue. Vladimir and Estragon both are waiting for Godot, they don't know Godot will come or not but they are waiting.
Q. 6 Do you agree: “The play (Waiting for Godot), we agreed, was a positive play, not negative, not pessimistic. As I saw it, with my blood and skin and eyes, the philosophy is: 'No matter what— atom bombs, hydrogen bombs, anything—life goes on. You can kill yourself, but you can't kill life." (E.G. Marshal who played Vladimir in original Broadway production 1950s)?
Yes, we can say that the play waiting for Godot is positive play because we can kill ourselves not life. We have a choice to kill ourselves but if we kill ourselves than can life stop? No life goes on. If we want to do suicide, it is bad as such but the important point is that does it matter for life? Always we have to do the same thing and we are always waiting for something in that manner life is meaningless but life lessons inspires to be positive. In anything life goes on.
Q. 7 How are the props like hat and boots used in the play? What is the symbolical significance of these props?
Hat is used as a tool of thinking. It is especially used for Lucky, when Lucky whear hat on his head he starts thinking. So we can say that hat is used as symbols of thinking. It also indirectly suggests that thinking is a process of our mind so hat can be on the head. Boots are used in the play.
Q. 8 Do you think that the obedience of Lucky is extremely irritating and Nauseatic? Even when the master Pozzo is blind, he obediently hands the whip in his hand. Do you think that such a capacity of slavishness is unbelievable?
Mastery sometimes hacked, blocked the mind into doing that is ordered by the master. If something is not important to carry on but then also people are going to be that. When humans have a choice to be free from this mastery sometimes then also they don't want to be free. In this picture we can see that master - slave relationship. Pozzo is a master and Lucky is a slave. Pozzo passes himself as master and Lucky as slave. We can see here rop is but many times we can't see such a top, religion, theological top we can't see that. Pozzo 's nature is uncaring Humanness. Vladimir continually asks Lucky that " Why doesn't he put down his bags? "
Here we can take an example of Sartre's idea about "Bad Faith ". Bad faith means that unnecessarily we are doing something. We have a choice to be free from this but we are not choosing that opportunity. Here in that picture we can see that Lucky have a choice but he is not grabbing an opportunity to be free. In act two, Pozzo become blind and Lucky become dumb. But Lucky is doing all as his master wants.
Q. 9 Who according to you is Godot? God? An object of desire? Death? Goal? Success? Or . . .
This play gives us an opportunity to interpret it in many ways. If we see dialogue of the play, especially Vladimir with Boy so can interpret with waiting is connected with Godot. People are always waiting for something, someone in life. It is part of our life, so we could not free ourselves from it, but the main point here is that our waiting never comes to the end. If we interpret Godot as god , we can say that God has a choice to do whatever they want. He is very cruel because, boy says he beating one of them. We have an image of God as he is very helpful, very kind, but here we find that if Godot is God than also he is not kind, he is crude, cruel as Hitler.
10 “The subject of the play is not Godot but ‘Waiting’” (Esslin, A Search for the Self). Do you agree? How can you justify your answer?
Yes, we can say that " Waiting for Godot " is not for God but it is waiting for something. As in the article "A Search for the Self" Martin Esslin suggests that it is for waiting not Godot, we can say that Godot itself is waiting. Human being always waiting for some kind of thing.
Q. 11 Do you think that plays like this can better be ‘read’ than ‘viewed’ as it requires a lot of thinking on the part of readers, while viewing, the torrent of dialogues does not give ample time and space to ‘think’? Or is it that the audio-visuals help in better understanding of the play?
Film as well as movie both are very much important to understand this play for better way. If we only seen movie of the play our international is half and if we read only text it is also difficult because we can not understood real meaning of the play. Dialogue helps a lot to interpret and understandings. Both are important.
Q 12 Which of the following sequence you liked the most:
o Vladimir – Estragon killing time in questions and conversations while waiting
Vladimir and Estragon: The Had and the Boot
o Pozzo – Lucky episode in both acts
o Conversation of Vladimir with the boy
Conversation of Vladimir with the boy is very interesting. both acts are very interesting. Idea of tomorrow's is never ends. Tomorrow never comes and Godot also never comes. Dialogues is here given below…
Act -1
BOY:
What am I to tell Mr. Godot, Sir?
VLADIMIR:
Tell him . . . (he hesitates) . . . tell him you saw us. (Pause.) You did see us, didn't you?
Act -2
BOY:
What am I to tell Mr. Godot, Sir?
VLADIMIR:
Tell him . . . (he hesitates) . . . tell him you saw me and that . . . (he hesitates) . . . that you saw me. (Pause. Vladimir advances, the Boy recoils. Vladimir halts, the Boy halts. With sudden violence.) You're sure you saw me, you won't come and tell me tomorrow that you never saw me!
So, it is very interesting .
Q 13 Did you feel the effect of existential crisis or meaninglessness of human existence in the irrational and indifference Universe during screening of the movie? Where and when exactly that feeling was felt, if ever it was?
Yes, we feel the effect of existential crisis or meaninglessness of human existence in the irrational and indifference universe . Idea of tomorrow itself is meaningless. Vladimir and Estragon, waiting for Godot without knowing , he coming or not, who he is, why we are waiting etc. Waiting is meaningless .
Q 14 Vladimir and Estragon talks about ‘hanging’ themselves and commit suicide, but they do not do so. How do you read this idea of suicide in Existentialism?
Can we do any political reading of the play if we see European nations represented by the 'names' of the characters (Vladimir - Russia; Estragon - France; Pozzo - Italy and Lucky - England)? What interpretation can be inferred from the play written just after World War II? Which country stands for 'Godot'?
Vladimir and Estragon both have a hope for Godot so they are not actually doing a suicide. Godot is stands for Germany. Why we are waiting, because we are afraid, fearful, so it can be seen that Godot as Germany.
Q 15 So far as Pozzo and Lucky [master and slave] are concerned, we have to remember that Beckett was a disciple of Joyce and that Joyce hated England. Beckett meant Pozzo to be England, and Lucky to be Ireland." (Bert Lahr who played Estragon in Broadway production). Does this reading make any sense? Why? How? What?
Pozzo is connected with England as he is seen it powerful position and Lucky is connected with Ireland as slaves. Irish people can't be free from their mastery, master is not there but still they are afraid. As Lucky don't want to be free from his master's order even he is blind.
Q 16 The more the things change, the more it remains similar. There seems to have no change in Act I and Act II of the play. Even the conversation between Vladimir and the Boy sounds almost similar. But there is one major change. In Act I, in reply to Boy;s question, Vladimir says:
"BOY: What am I to tell Mr. Godot, Sir?
VLADIMIR: Tell him . . . (he hesitates) . . . tell him you saw us. (Pause.) You did see us, didn't you?
How does this conversation go in Act II? Is there any change in seeming similar situation and conversation? If so, what is it? What does it signify?
Yes, there's little bit change in both acts. Vladimir becomes Self centric in act 2 . This change seems that selfishness of human being.
No comments:
Post a Comment