Sunday, November 29, 2020

Thinking Activity : Movie screening of the play The Birthday Party

 Thinking Activity : Movie screening of the play The Birthday Party


Welcome Readers! 


Here are some questions and film screening of the play The Birthday Party, 1968, British drama film, directed by William Friedkin. The crypt for the film was written by Pinter. 


Post - viewing tasks : 


1.Why are two scenes of Lulu omitted from the movie?


The Birthday Party is a play of comedy of menace, it means dangerous and threatening quality. So,Director doesn't want to change the tone of the genre of the play. Lulu is also an inspiration for Stanley . 


2.Is movie successful in giving us the effect of menace? Where you able to feel it while reading the text?


Harold Pinter is associated with the idea of comedy of menace. We know that audio and visuals given more threatening than reading. In the movie we feel that comedy of menace. Use of pause and silent makes it more effective. In the movie we feel that comedy of menace. When Stanley listen that two strangers come, his loudness, constants asking questions and he seems  frustrated and fearful. Beginning sequence, closing doors, close up to camera there also we feel comedy of menace. 


3.Do you feel the effect of lurking danger while viewing the movie? Where you able to feel the same while reading the text ? 


Yes, doors knocking and in the introgression scenes we feel the effects of lurking  while viewing the movie. Scene of kitchen and introgression scenes, Stanley hide himself. Yes we can also feel that while reading the play. 


4.What do you read in 'newspaper' in the movie? Petey is reading newspaper to Meg, it torn into pieces by McCain, pieces are hidden by Petey in last scene.


Especially in act two we find the newspaper as symbol of power position. To hide ourselves and as a mask. Petey is reading a newspaper to Meg , it can be seen as man is in power position. 


5.Camera is positioned over the head of McCain when he is playing Blind Man's Buff and is positioned at the top with a view of room like a cage (trap) when Stanley is playing it. What interpretations can you give to these positioning of camera?


Camera is a very important tool for movie. Camera also tells a story which directors  not make's it very openly. In this movie we finds camera played a very important role. 

Camera is positioned over the head of McCain and it seems like he wants to emotionally blackmailed to Stanley. Other movement of camera is like Stanley is in room and camera moved as it is prison and Stanley wants to escape but he can't. 


6."Pinter restored theater to its basic elements: an enclosed space and unpredictable dialogue, where people are at the mercy of one another and pretense crumbles." (Pinter, Art, Truth & Politics: Excerpts from the 2005 Nobel Lecture). Does this happen in the movie?


Yes, this happened in this movie. Dialogues and rubbish thoughts of character's mind and also they all are dependent on each other. And once upon a time they came to really. 


7. How does viewing movies help in better understanding of the play ‘The Birthday Party’ with its typical characteristics (like painteresque, pause, silence, menace, lurking danger)?


Reading and viewing both is important for any understanding of work. This movie is helping us to understand the use of pause, menace, silence, etc. While watching the movie we feel menace. So it's helpful. 



8.With which of the following observations you agree:



o   “It probably wasn't possible to make a satisfactory film of "The Birthday Party."



o    “It's impossible to imagine a better film of Pinter's play than this sensitive, disturbing version directed by William Friedkin”. (Ebert)



I agree with second point that it's impossible to imagine a better film of Pinter's play than this sensitive, disturbing version directed by William Friedkin. First point seems like it is impossible but it is not impossible to makes satisfactory movie of Pinter's play. Yes it is difficult but not impossible. This movie is good . Use of music, different voices and movement of camera angles make this movie more appropriate for the play. 


9. If you were a director or screenplay writer, what sort of difference would you make in the making of a movie?


I think there is no need to change but if I got a chance to make something else than I like to change the time of some scenes. There is little bit long sound of newspaper and long scenes of boring ongoing things. So first I make it short and give it music. 


10.Who would be your choice of actors to play the role of characters?


Lulu          -  Priyanka Chopra

Meg          -  Kirron Khair

Stanley     -  Irfan Khan, Vicky Kaushal

Goldberg  -  Saif Ali Khan 

McCain    -  Anupam Khair

Petey       -  Nasruddin Shah  



Wednesday, November 25, 2020

Thinking Activity : Movie Screening of the play Waiting for Godot


Thinking Activity : Movie Screening of the play Waiting for Godot 


Welcome readers! 

This  blog is about some points to be ponder it. We have to give our internation to all questions. 

Q. 1 What connection do you see in the setting (“A country road. A tree.Evening.”) of the play and these paintings?


                   


In this painting we find it as very romantic but in the movie of the play " Waiting for Godot there this picture is Shawn as very dull. Existential vision of life is not romantic. Nothing to be done in the play, two ,Vladimir and Estragon are waiting for Godot but it never comes. Setting of the play is very differentiate  country road, tree and evening is there but not as it seems in this painting.  


Q. 2  The tree is the only important ‘thing’ in the setting. What is the importance of tree in both acts? Why does Beckett grow a few leaves in Act II on the barren tree - The tree has four or five leaves - ?


                                


He look's a barren tree with green leaves. The Barrenness of nature  is seen here in the picture. At every moment we are waiting for something. The setting of the play tree is always there in both act. It deep satire on the all theological concerns.  

Tree also give an idea of strength and waiting. Maybe tree have four, five leaves 

    


Q.3 In both Acts, evening falls into night and moon rises. How would you like to interpret this ‘coming of night and moon’ when actually they are waiting for Godot?

 

                    

 Night and Moon, Waiting for Godot 


Here we can say that night and moon both we can see. Darkness and light we find in the picture. Darkness we can say that it is waiting and Shines we can say theirs believed that every moon light comes with allusion for Godot. It seems like Timepasses. Nothing to be done. 



Q. 4  The director feels the setting with some debris. Can you read any meaning in the contours of debris in the setting of the play?


Yes, the director used debris in the setting. Director wants to reminded an effects of World War. Nothing is permanent the life. That way we can see the use of debris. 


Q. 5 The play begins with the dialogue “Nothing to be done”. How does the theme of ‘nothingness’ recurs in the play?


"Nothing to be done " itself suggest that waiting for Godot can never end. In our life we are waiting for something, somebody without knowing ,that for whom we are waiting? What is the purpose of our waiting?  Why are we waiting? Existentialism says that all we are doing ,it is nothing, kind of timepass. We know that doing something is meaningless but still we are doing. Play starting with this dialogue. Vladimir and Estragon both are waiting for Godot, they don't know Godot will come or not but they are waiting. 


 Q. 6  Do you agree: “The play (Waiting for Godot), we agreed, was a positive play, not negative, not pessimistic. As I saw it, with my blood and skin and eyes, the philosophy is: 'No matter what— atom bombs, hydrogen bombs, anything—life goes on. You can kill yourself, but you can't kill life." (E.G. Marshal who played Vladimir in original Broadway production 1950s)?


Yes, we can say that the play waiting for Godot is positive play because we can kill ourselves not life. We have a choice to kill ourselves but if we kill ourselves than can life stop? No life goes on. If we want to do suicide, it is bad as such but the important point is that does it matter for life? Always we have to do the same thing and we are always waiting for something in that manner life is meaningless but life lessons inspires to be positive. In anything life goes on. 


Q. 7   How are the props like hat and boots used in the play? What is the symbolical significance of these props?


Hat is used as a tool of thinking. It is especially used for Lucky, when Lucky whear hat on his head he starts thinking. So we can say that hat is used as symbols of thinking. It also indirectly suggests that thinking is a process of our mind so hat can be on the head. Boots are used in the play. 



Q. 8 Do you think that the obedience of Lucky is extremely irritating and Nauseatic? Even when the master Pozzo is blind, he obediently hands the whip in his hand. Do you think that such a capacity of slavishness is unbelievable?


               


Mastery sometimes hacked, blocked the mind into doing that is ordered by the master. If something is not important to carry on but then also people are going to be that. When humans have a choice to be free from this mastery sometimes then also they don't want to be free. In this picture we can see that master - slave relationship. Pozzo is a master and Lucky is a slave. Pozzo passes himself as master and Lucky as slave. We can see here rop is but many times we can't see such a top, religion, theological top we can't see that. Pozzo 's nature is uncaring Humanness. Vladimir continually asks Lucky that " Why doesn't he put down his bags? " 


Here we can take an example of Sartre's idea about "Bad Faith ". Bad faith means that unnecessarily we are doing something. We have a choice to be free from this but we are not choosing that opportunity. Here in that picture we can see that Lucky have a choice but he is not grabbing  an opportunity to be free. In act two, Pozzo become blind and Lucky become dumb. But Lucky is doing all as his master wants. 


Q. 9  Who according to you is Godot? God? An object of desire? Death? Goal? Success? Or  . . .


 This play gives us an opportunity to interpret it in many ways. If we see dialogue of the play, especially Vladimir with Boy so can interpret with waiting is connected with Godot. People are always waiting for something, someone in life. It is part of our life, so we could not free ourselves from it, but the main point here is that our waiting never comes to the end. If we interpret Godot as god , we can say that God has a choice to do whatever they want. He is very cruel because, boy says he beating one of them. We have an image of God as he is very helpful, very kind, but here we find that if Godot is God than also he is not kind, he is crude, cruel as Hitler. 



10 “The subject of the play is not Godot but ‘Waiting’” (Esslin, A Search for the Self). Do you agree? How can you justify your answer?


Yes, we can say that " Waiting for Godot " is not for God but it is waiting for something. As in the article "A Search for the Self" Martin Esslin suggests that it is for waiting not Godot, we can say that Godot itself is waiting. Human being always waiting for some kind of thing. 


Q. 11    Do you think that plays like this can better be ‘read’ than ‘viewed’ as it requires a lot of thinking on the part of readers, while viewing, the torrent of dialogues does not give ample time and space to ‘think’? Or is it that the audio-visuals help in better understanding of the play?


Film as well as movie both are very much important to understand this play for better way. If we only seen movie of the play our international is half and if we read only text it is also difficult because we can not understood real meaning of the play. Dialogue helps a lot to interpret and understandings. Both are important. 


Q 12  Which of the following sequence you liked the most:


 



o   Vladimir – Estragon killing time in questions and conversations while waiting


Vladimir and Estragon: The Had and the Boot


o   Pozzo – Lucky episode in both acts

o   Conversation of Vladimir with the boy


Conversation of Vladimir with the boy is very interesting. both acts are very interesting. Idea of tomorrow's is never ends. Tomorrow never comes and Godot also never comes. Dialogues is here given below… 


Act -1 


BOY: 

What am I to tell Mr. Godot, Sir? 

VLADIMIR: 

Tell him . . . (he hesitates) . . . tell him you saw us. (Pause.) You did see us, didn't you? 



Act -2 


BOY: 

What am I to tell Mr. Godot, Sir? 

VLADIMIR: 

Tell him . . . (he hesitates) . . . tell him you saw me and that . . . (he hesitates) . . . that you saw me. (Pause. Vladimir advances, the Boy recoils. Vladimir halts, the Boy halts. With sudden violence.) You're sure you saw me, you won't come and tell me tomorrow that you never saw me!


So, it is very interesting . 


Q 13  Did you feel the effect of existential crisis or meaninglessness of human existence in the irrational and indifference Universe during screening of the movie? Where and when exactly that feeling was felt, if ever it was?


Yes, we feel the effect of existential crisis or meaninglessness of human existence in the irrational and indifference universe . Idea of tomorrow itself is meaningless. Vladimir and Estragon, waiting for Godot without knowing , he coming or not, who he is, why we are waiting etc. Waiting is meaningless . 


Q 14  Vladimir and Estragon talks about ‘hanging’ themselves and commit suicide, but they do not do so. How do you read this idea of suicide in Existentialism?

Can we do any political reading of the play if we see European nations represented by the 'names' of the characters (Vladimir - Russia; Estragon - France; Pozzo - Italy and Lucky - England)? What interpretation can be inferred from the play written just after World War II? Which country stands for 'Godot'?


Vladimir and Estragon both have a hope for Godot so they are not actually doing a suicide. Godot is stands for Germany. Why we are waiting, because we are afraid, fearful, so it can be seen that Godot as Germany. 



 Q 15  So far as Pozzo and Lucky [master and slave] are concerned, we have to remember that Beckett was a disciple of Joyce and that Joyce hated England. Beckett meant Pozzo to be England, and Lucky to be Ireland." (Bert Lahr who played Estragon in Broadway production). Does this reading make any sense? Why? How? What?


Pozzo is connected with England as he is seen it powerful position and Lucky is connected with Ireland as slaves. Irish people can't be free from their mastery, master is not there but still they are afraid. As Lucky don't want to be free from his master's order even he is blind. 


Q 16 The more the things change, the more it remains similar. There seems to have no change in Act I and Act II of the play. Even the conversation between Vladimir and the Boy sounds almost similar. But there is one major change. In Act I, in reply to Boy;s question, Vladimir says: 


"BOY: What am I to tell Mr. Godot, Sir?

VLADIMIR: Tell him . . . (he hesitates) . . . tell him you saw us. (Pause.) You did see us, didn't you?

How does this conversation go in Act II? Is there any change in seeming similar situation and conversation? If so, what is it? What does it signify?


Yes, there's little bit change in both acts. Vladimir becomes Self centric in act 2 . This change seems that selfishness of human being. 



Monday, November 23, 2020

Sunday reading, Ecocriticism

 Ecocriticism 


Nowadays, ecocriticism is required . Environmental studies takes place . We love and like natural beauty but when we take responsibility to save environmental sources at that time we fail. Human beings do development and we fail many times to think about it. Ecocritics ask several questions like… 


How is nature represented in the text? 


How can we characterize nature writing as a genre? 


How do our metaphors of the land influence the way we treat it? 


As ecocritic Lawrence Buell says, ecocriticism is an " Increasingly heterogeneous movement " 

 


It Introgates narrative of human progress by juxtapositioning human impact on Flora and fauna and their natural habits. We all are contributing I'm deforestation, in our e or other way. Many times we remove things, furniture etc., which has a long ability to be worked but we remove that and set new things. For eco sensitive people, cutting of trees is for them like murder. Ecocritics would criticize Wordsworth. His poetry are good but where are the real effects of industrialization? 


Technology and Ecology 


"Human culture is connected to the physical world, affecting it and affected by it "



We have to work together. Development is good for live easier but we have to keep in mind that we have to see both  sides. Roads, dams were developed, the need of today, we are not only living in this planet but there are many. We have to see, what is developing and what is damaging. Damagers also help us. Machines, industries, factories etc, technology help us but with ecological concerns , one has to make both develop. We can save trees and nature by using it in a proper way. Buildings are developed but we can care for trees outside of the building. 


So, Ecocriticism is an amazing study. Nature teach us how to connect ourselves with others. Tree near tree 🌲🌲 . Tree may not have words, languages as we have but it has their own language . 


References 


https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/subject_specific_writing/writing_in_literature/literary_theory_and_schools_of_criticism/ecocriticism.html



Film reviews

 Film Reviews


Welcome Readers! 


Midnight's Children, Reluctant Fundamentalism … 


Books and Movies 


Literary works make us entertainment and also aware about reality with form of history. Movies are not only an entertainment but it given us deeper meaning. Visualization speaks more.What makes a good book and what makes a good movie are totally different things.

We read a book and seen movie , this experience is totally different. 


Comparing a book to a movie is like comparing glasses to a mirror. The same ingredient doesn’t make them similar.


Introduction : 


Postcolonial literature is not emerging after freedom but it is already there. So what is postcolonial literature? In the broadest terms, this category includes works that have a relationship to the subjugating forces of imperialism and colonial expansion. In short, questions relating to the political and cultural independence of formerly subjugated people. Who speak about that problems of slavery, subaltern erc. Many writers choose such a theme for their writing like contemporary issues, social issues and about subaltern etc. 


Midnight's Children


Salman Rushdie as a postcolonial writer, who wrote many more about contemporary, social and political issues. One of the best example of his work is a controversial novel " Midnight's Children " . It is adapted into a movie by Deepa Mehta. 


Identity is problematic here, all suffering from their identity. Saleem is Shiva and Shiva is Saleem, Nurse exchanged them when they're born. Title is also interesting to see that children born at midnight when India got freedom. There was a partition with India and Pakistan. So from the very beginning to the movie with Kashmir 1917. 


People have a problem with narration , that broken images . Other images like ,Taj Mahal image is far away, hidden but seen in dull. Whenever we see Agra there is a full screen of Taj Mahal but here in this movie it is different. Group of muslim , they don't want to partition of India and Pakistan but there voice was silent at that time, but in movie this voice is raise. Another thing is Spittoon is used here as a symbol. We can see it beginning to end . 


Reluctant Fundamentalism


We are many times attracted to America, statues of liberty, an idea of freedom. We have misconceptions about America. Changez Khan telling about America, what he seen there, and how American people are behaved and how investigations happened. He respects American culture and professionalism. Changez's narration is unique to other 9/11 novels. after the backlash of 9/11 , how they become victims and legitimate targets of hate crimes,disappearance, negative media stereotypes, physical beatings, interrogations at American airports. It addresses how such treatment sheds light on the questions of Muslim integration in the American society, citizenship, multiculturalism. 


Write a story or history or any literary work in its full manner without missing anything that is very much important. Changez's tell to journalist to  take full story not beasts, pieces but in totality. What we see and what we listen, if we conclude it to same way with different perspectives or ways we have to be very alert about results, that if we are missing something then what? 



Saturday, November 21, 2020

Flipped Learning : Existentialism

 Flipped Learning : Existentialism 


Welcome Readers! 


 Here in this blog post, we have to watch some videos and reading resources for better understanding of existentialism with the help to get new experience of flipped learning class. So it is interesting to see and learn about existentialism. 


To know more about this task you can

 click here  . 



Here I give some thoughts which I like from  all the videos , 


Video : 1   What is Existentialism? 


Existentialism is about an individuality, freedom and passion. Triangle is interesting to see existentialism, idea with triangle. In this video I like the idea of Camus, that is philosophical suicide. He says that believing in God is considered philosophy called suicide for him. Our believe in God & religion is our escapism. We catch readymade ideas or answers by others. When we want to escape from thinking it's called philosophical suicide. So Albert Camus idea of philosophical suicide is very interesting . Existentialism says that to think rational. 


Video : 2  The Myth of Sisyphus



Feelings of absurdity,people think that life is full of meaningless, absurd and ultimate solutions to dies. Suicide is an individual thought. Suicide is a result of our absurd thought process. When humans want to escape from life and want to make death mistress. That's seems that it is humans desire not fear of death. 


Video : 3  The Myth of Sisyphus 


The notion of philosophical suicide we can find in this video. Why the absurdity takes place? So it is a total absence of hope, a continual rejection and conscious dissatisfaction, these kinds of conflict between human and World. There can be no absurdity outside the human mind. Camus makes it very clear that philosophical suicide is to escape from thinking, reasons, questions. 


Video : 4 Dadaism, Nihilism and        Existentialism 


Dadaism is a quest for change. Creation is a primary goal of Dadaism. Dadaism and Nihilism have nothing to do with each other. These three movements are different from each other. Dadaism is a quest for new value. 


Video :5  Existentialism - a gloomy philosophy 


Why it can be called gloomy philosophy? So existentialism came after the second World War , time to find meaning in life. Life is full of absurdity, anxiety. People are free to choose whatever they want but yes with our right, responsibility plays a very vital role. 


Video : 6  Existentialism and Nihilism : Is it one and the same? 


No, it is not same, every existentialism is against their Nihilism one or other way.  For Kierkegaard Nihilism is the loss of individuality. For Nietzsche Nihilism is that the highest values devaluate themselves. So divine  perspective comes with immortality , which ignores an important human moral perspective. Existentialism is with subjectivity and Nihilism is with objectivity. 


Video : 7 Let us introduce Existentialism again! 


It examines Sartre ' statement that " Existence precedes essence " . Human existence is in centers.Defines purpose or desire of life is not very much important in existentialism. So maybe we can say that as an answer to the question, what is the meaning or purpose of our life, existentialism denied this question because in whatever way we have to live. We know sometimes there is nothing like meaning but then also we are living. 


Video : 8  Existentialism & Nietzsche


We find here Nietzsche' view about concepts of existentialism, it is quite interesting. He gives an idea of "Ubermensche"  .Make our own rules is very much important. Here is one point that's  better to find your own way rather than to walk in others paths. Find your own way that is an amazing thing. 


Video : 9 Why I like existentialism? Eric Dadson 


Existentialism has two sides, 

One is Intellectual and Second is movement of extraordinary. Existentialism gave us a sense of deeper thinking, it will help us to find in right way in our life. 


Video : 10 Let us sum up : From essentialism to existentialism 


This video is very interesting to see. We have to make our own way to live. We have a choice to choose our path, that what we want to be but sometimes it is very much difficult to choose our individual way. Because there are also many more choices to choose but it is not an individual choice. Here is one example of an army man, who wants to serve his mother and nation at the same time. So it is an individual Choice to make our own path . 


Which video I like the most? Why? 


All videos are very much interesting and I like all but the last video I like the most because it provides us to how to live life and we have to make our own path to walk rather than to walk in other's paths. The idea of taking decisions is quite difficult but that is the struggle.


Thank you… 


Friday, November 20, 2020

Breath by Samuel Beckett

 Interpretation Challenge : The Shortest Play " Breath " by Samuel Beckett



Welcome Readers! 


In this blog post, I try to give an interpretation of  thirty seconds play "Breath " by Samuel Beckett, he is also associated with Theatre of Absurd . Martin Esslin first gives the term "Theatre of Absurd ".


The Script of the play 


CURTAIN Up


1. Faint light on stage littered with miscellaneous rubbish. Hold about five seconds.


2. Faint brief cry and immediately inspiration and slow increase of light together reaching maximum - together in about ten seconds. Silence and hold for about five seconds.


3. Expiration and slow decrease of light together reaching minimum together (light as in 1) in about ten seconds and immediately cry as before. Silence and hold about five seconds. 


CURTAIN Down

 

Click on the link to know more about this play and to watch some videos of this play. 

(https://blog.dilipbarad.com/2014/09/interpretation-challenge-breath.html?m=1) 


Interpretation of the play : 


"Breath" is a very short play by Samuel Beckett. It seems Absurdity and Meaninglessness . But these words like Breath,Cry are very short but provide deeper significance of play. Breath signifies life. Cry is not mean that "Tears falling from the eyes" but it means that our quest for power, money desire for high status and many more. We also find use of light, from the very begining of the play and end of the play sounds signifies begining of life and ending of life, birth and death.


Wednesday, November 11, 2020

A Tempest

 Thinking Activity : A Tempest 

 


"A tempest " as a Postcolonial play, Contemporariness of those issues. For Aime Cesaire, art material production. A Temple has historical context. Postcolonialism based on the control of land, space, colony etc. For Cesaire imperialism is about attitude. Colonialism is forcible, you can govern it when you know. White magic of prosperous is too powerful. Land is crucial, land also needs what can see. Prospero as not democratic man. Cesaire is trying to argue that land is ok to question. Caliban is an articulation. Caliban has a wonderful way, but he lacks power to change autocratic mode. At the end of Cesaire 'play people are not ready to except modernity. Land is open question in Cesaire, anybody can challenge the colonizers position. What Shakespeare 's play Caliban lacks is Caliban's ability to organize resistance in a big way .


" A Tempest " is a play by Aime Cesaire, an adaptation from Shakespeare's play " The Tempest". Shakespeare's play define colonialism and Cesaire's play with postcolonial perspective. End of both the play are very different.


The idea of the rebel


Albert Camus "Plague"

Albert Camus " Rebel"


It question tradition, who and what makes rebel. Not follow norms of society, that makes us critic not rebellion. It is not individual act. Rebel is individual but rebellion is not an individual act. So in Shakespeare's play Caliban is critic of society not rebellion. Caliban only think about himself not for whole. But in Cesaire's play Caliban is rebellion, he think about everyone not only for himself. We can't be a rebel without plan. Caliban showing signs that language can be use against colonial.


Thank you...



Assignment : Mass Communication and Media Studies

  Name           : Komal Jadav Paper           : Mass                         Communication                         and media Studies       ...