Ecofeminism and Ecocriticism
Ecofeminism
Ecofeminism, like the social movements it has emerged from, is both political activism and intellectual critique. Bringing together feminism and environmentalism, ecofeminism argues that the domination of women and the degradation of the environment are consequences of patriarchy and capitalism. Any strategy to address one must take into account its impact on the other so that women's equality should not be achieved at the expense of worsening the environment, and neither should environmental improvements be gained at the expense of women. Indeed, ecofeminism proposes that only by reversing current values, thereby privileging care and cooperation over more aggressive and dominating behaviors, can both society and environment benefit.
The notion that women's and environmental domination are linked has been developed in a number of ways. A perspective in which women are accredited with closer links with nature was celebrated in early ecofeminist writings, by, for example, Carolyn Merchant in the United States and Val Plumwood in Australia. These advocated ‘the feminine principle’ as an antidote to environmental destruction, through attributes, which nurture nature. This ‘essentialist’ perspective, often adopting an ideal of woman as earth mother/goddess, has, however, also discredited ecofeminism and led to disaffection among some early protagonists (see, for example, Janet Biehl). In addition to being critiqued for its essentialism, this view of ecofeminism has also been charged with elitism through its provenance in a white, middle-class, Western, milieu. However, Vandana Shiva's consistent and persuasive ‘majority world’ voice has been a counterpoint to this, and arguably, gender and environment have been articulated together more powerfully, and been more influential, in majority world settings (see, for example, Wangari Maathai in Kenya), although how this has been done has been questioned by writers such as Cecile Jackson and Melisssa Leach.
The late 1980s and early 1990s was a fertile time for ecofeminist writing, both from this essentialist perspective, but also through more social economic critiques, which explained the link between women's inequality and environmental degradation in terms of women's role in social reproduction (see, for example, Mary Mellor in the UK and Marilyn Waring in New Zealand).
The first major practical impact of ecofeminist thinking was felt in the 1992 United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), which women's environmental organizations had lobbied for women's and environmental rights to be considered in tandem. This, and the 1995 4th Women's Conference in Beijing, agreed for the first time that women's rights and environmental rights could not be disentangled.
By the late 1990s, however, the output on ecofeminism had dropped significantly and there was a sense of it having run out of steam, despite its arguable influence revealed through UN initiatives. However, in the new millennium, a new generation of writers, researchers, and activists has reinvigorated ecofeminist debates, through considerations of ecofeminist citizenship (Sherilyn MacGregor), challenges to some earlier critiques (Niamh Moore), and insertion of feminist concerns into environmental justice (Susan Buckingham and Rakibe Kulcur, and Giovanna di Chiro) and political ecology (Wendy Harcourt, Dianne Rocheleau).
This article considers the heritage of ecofeminism as a multiply braided political praxis and an intellectual position. It examines key critiques of earlier perspectives, before exploring its more recent developments. It considers its relationship with, and potential to enhance other feminist and environmental approaches, particularly those concerned with feminist political ecology and environmental justice. The article concludes with a consideration of how ecofeminism is enjoying a resurgence through a new generation of academics seeking to develop and nuance ecofeminism from a sympathetic position, the emergence of climate change as a major global issue, and the development of social movements in areas not previously associated with feminist environmental action, notably in the Middle East.
Ecocriticism
Ecocriticism is the study of literature and the environment from an interdisciplinary point of view, where literature scholars analyze texts that illustrate environmental concerns and examine the various ways literature treats the subject of nature. It takes an interdisciplinary point of view by analysing the works of authors, researchers and poets in the context of environmental issues and nature.[1] Some ecocritics brainstorm possible solutions for the correction of the contemporary environmental situation, though not all ecocritics agree on the purpose, methodology, or scope of ecocriticism.
In the United States, ecocriticism is often associated with the Association for the Study of Literature and Environment (ASLE),[2] which hosts a biennial conference for scholars who deal with environmental matters in literature and the environmental humanities in general. ASLE publishes a journal—Interdisciplinary Studies in Literature and Environment (ISLE)—in which current international scholarship can be found.
Ecocriticism is an intentionally broad approach that is known by a number of other designations, including "green (cultural) studies", "ecopoetics", and "environmental literary criticism", and is often informed by other fields such as ecology, sustainable design, biopolitics, environmental history, environmentalism, and social ecology, among others.
Glotfelty calls the "undervalued genre of nature writing".[3] Lawrence Buell defines "'ecocriticism' ... as [a] study of the relationship between literature and the environment conducted in a spirit of commitment to environmentalist praxis".[4]